While the state accuses him of sexually abusing a child while in a position of trust, former Foreign Minister Abdulla Shahid has argued in the High Court that he does not have a stepchild.
64-year-old Shahid, who also served as the President of the UN General Assembly, was arrested early this month after a case alleging that he molested a minor surfaced. He is currently detained in prison under a 30-day remand order issued by the Criminal Court.
In the form submitted by the state to the court to remand Shahid, the victimized child was stated to be Shahid's stepchild.
In the case submitted by Shahid's side to the High Court to appeal that order, his argument is that the child is not his stepchild. Shahid's side also noted in court that stating the child is his stepchild and listing the accusation of the offense of a person in a position of trust engaging in a sexual act with a minor on the form was unlawful.
Shahid's side stated in court that the arrest warrant did not accuse him of the offense of engaging in a sexual act with a minor, and that the court's decision to remand him based on an accusation not stated in the form was unlawful.
In court, the Prosecutor General's Office noted that from the statements submitted with the case, the child addresses Shahid as 'Bappi,' and that there are matters indicating the child believes Shahid to be the child's stepfather.
However, the verdict delivered today by the High Court stated that the accusation of the offense was made against him even at the time Shahid was arrested and given the legal warning, and therefore, this claim that the offense cannot be regarded as an accusation not made or unable to be made against him cannot be accepted, nor can his arrest and detention be considered as being based on an accusation that cannot be made.
The order issued by the lower court in this case states that there is sufficient evidence to support the allegations raised against the accused. However, the point appealed by Shahid's side stated that he was arrested and detained relying on incorrect evidence.
However, the High Court's verdict stated that, based on the documents and statements submitted to the lower court in connection with the case, there are no grounds to suggest that the charges against Shahid was made incorrectly.
The verdict states that while additional documents corroborating the statements obtained for the investigation have also been submitted, this is a circumstance where evidence can be considered to exist to keep a person in detention in such a case during the investigation stage.
The verdict also noted that at this stage, it cannot be determined whether the evidence submitted by the state is admissible in trial or not.
Shahid's side also noted in court that there was no statement from the child when Shahid was arrested and accused. They said that what the police possess is the statement of the person to whom the victimized child recounted those events.
The verdict stated that at the current stage of the case, what the lower court judge must look at is whether or not there is some degree of evidence of the offense against the accused.
"In determining that, having the child's statement is not mandatory. When a person to whom the child recounted those events has recounted that story to the investigation, if it can be believed from those accounts and the other evidence obtained in the case that some degree of suspicion of the offense can be raised against the accused, stating that along with reasons will suffice," the verdict states.
Therefore, the High Court ruled that there are no grounds to declare the order issued by the Criminal Court to remand Shahid as void.




